> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://yvindy.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Steamboat's Home Base pays about $119,000 a home, and its buyers' incomes average in the city's top bracket
- URL: https://yvindy.com/steamboat-home-base-buyer-incomes/
- Published: 2026-11-20T21:48:32.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-20T21:48:32.000Z
- Description: Council members pushed back on paying existing owners who live in their homes to join Home Base but signaled support for $3 million more. The 10 households helped so far reported incomes averaging 152% of area median income, and the program has no income cap, its administrator says.
- Author: Anna Parashina
- Tags: Government, Steamboat Springs, Housing, city council

## Key points

- Steamboat Springs has spent or committed an average of about $119,000 in short-term rental tax money per home through its Home Base Steamboat program, which has closed seven purchases and has three more under contract since it launched June 16, according to a city review presented Nov. 17.
- Those 10 households reported incomes averaging 152% of area median income, in the bracket the city's housing needs assessment labels "Upper Income," which holds 37% of all county households. That average is above the incomes of more than six in 10 Routt County households and more than half of county homeowners, by the Independent's calculation from the city's table. Individual buyers ranged from 64% to 231%.
- Nine of the 10 chose the deed restriction that limits resale to local workers but puts no cap on the resale price, according to the review.
- The main pushback at council's Nov. 17 review was to a proposed addition: paying existing owners who live in their homes for deed restrictions. Council member Dave Barnes said it "seems like a total home equity loan," and council passed the program's deed restriction changes 7-0 on first reading with direction to remove that option. Members also signaled support for adding $3 million for 2027 and, in informal votes, backed higher maximum payments, which would extend the full payment to homes priced up to $1.3 million by the Independent's calculation, and a wider eligible area. None of it is final.
- There is no income cap or asset limit, said the Yampa Valley Housing Authority, which administers Home Base, though at least one household member must work at least 30 hours a week for an employer located in Routt County; the deed restriction makes room for local workers who are retired or disabled. Staff called the pilot successful and said it serves households from low to upper incomes. The city did not respond by noon Friday to the Independent's questions.

Steamboat Springs has spent or committed an average of about $119,000 in short-term rental tax money per home through its Home Base program, according to a city review presented to City Council on Nov. 17\. The 10 households getting that money reported incomes averaging 152% of area median income — above the incomes of more than six in 10 Routt County households, by the Independent's calculation from the city's figures.

The review, by Housing Innovation Specialist Kayley McCarthy, showed buyer incomes from 64% to 231% of area median income. A table from the city's 2026 housing needs assessment, printed on the same slide, labels households above 140% "Upper Income" and puts 37% of all Routt County households in that group. That leaves 63% of all households at or below 140%, by the Independent's calculation, and the table shows 56% of households that own their homes at or below that line.

Nine of the 10 buyers chose the deed restriction that limits resale to local workers but sets no cap on the resale price, according to the review. At council's Nov. 17 review of the pilot, the pushback centered on a proposed addition: paying existing owners who live in their homes to sell the city a deed restriction. Council members opposed it, and staff said it wasn't advocating for it. Members did signal support for more money and, in informal votes, backed higher maximum payments and letting buyers use the program outside city limits. None of it is final. City staff called the pilot successful and said it is serving households from low to upper incomes.

## Pushback on paying existing owners

Staff had recommended opening Home Base to existing homeowners, with $1 million set aside, following direction council gave in February. Under staff's proposal, an existing owner would have had to live in the home when the deed restriction was recorded and meet the program's other eligibility rules; new buyers, by contrast, get the city's payment when they buy. The staff memo said the approach "would result in lasting deed restrictions, preserving the property for local occupancy through multiple future owners." Council's own Housing Sub-Committee, made up of council President Steve Muntean and council member Bryan Swintek, had directed staff in October to open the program to existing owners and to put off letting employers take part, according to an Oct. 15 staff memo.

At the meeting, staff said it was not advocating for the option and had brought it because of council's February direction, adding that it was "perfectly fine" if council would rather keep the program to new homebuyers. Council member Dave Barnes said the option "seems like a total home equity loan," while praising the program for new buyers. In the same remarks, he suggested increasing the payments and widening the area the program covers, changes council later backed. One speaker said the option's advantage is keeping those homes out of the short-term rental and second-home market.

Council members opposed adding existing owners; one said they would support it only with an appreciation cap. Barnes then moved to pass the deed restriction amendments on first reading, with direction to remove the existing-owner language before second reading. Council President Pro Tem Gail Garey seconded, and the motion passed 7-0\. The amendments would also give the city new powers to advance money to cure a mortgage default and place a lien on the home, and, as a last resort, to compel the sale of a home to another eligible household.

The staff memo says cure advances "are expected to be relatively small and uncommon and would be funded from the Home Base Steamboat program appropriation," and it lists the ordinance's fiscal impact as "None." It also says the city "is accepting a small risk of losing one or more of its investments in deed restrictions in return for achieving the housing benefits the program offers."

## How Home Base works

The city launched Home Base Steamboat on June 16, with the Yampa Valley Housing Authority as its partner. It is paid for with the city's short-term rental tax, which the city levies "for the purpose of providing funding to increase the stock of affordable and attainable housing," according to an ordinance on the Nov. 17 agenda. The same ordinance finds that buying these deed restrictions "promotes the purpose of the STR Tax and is consistent with the terms of the ballot question."

The Yampa Valley Housing Authority is the program administrator for the Home Base pilot, said Laraine Martin, the authority's communications manager. The authority takes applications and oversees the initial qualification process, and city staff give final approval. It also coordinates closing and funding deadlines and oversees the recording of the deed restriction at closing, she said.

Buyers choose one of two deed restrictions, according to the review.

- **Local Residency:** the city pays 15% of the purchase price, up to $150,000, with no cap on resale price.
- **Price-Capped:** the city pays 25%, up to $250,000, and appreciation is capped at 3% a year or the annual rise in area median income, whichever is lower. The amended deed restriction now before council would instead cap appreciation at the lesser of 3% or the yearly rise in Routt County's average wage.

Both require local employment or retirement from a local job, and the home must be the owner's primary residence. Buyers can't own other residential property, a staff member told council, and the restriction stays with the home, so later buyers must qualify too.

Home Base has no income cap or asset limit, Martin said. At least one member of a buyer's household must work at least 30 hours a week for an employer located in Routt County, she said; the deed restriction also allows for local workers who can't meet that rule because of disability or retirement. Martin pointed to the city's [program FAQ](https://www.steamboatsprings.net/DocumentCenter/View/42496/Pilot-Program-FAQ-updated-Remediated?bidId=&ref=yvindy.com) for more on eligibility. Neither the review nor the amended deed restriction now before council sets an income limit.

## Who has used it

As of Nov. 17, the city had issued 30 approval letters and fielded 114 inquiries, according to the review. Seven purchases had closed and three more were under contract. An approval letter doesn't guarantee a payment, which depends on money being available, staff told council.

Purchase prices ranged from $455,000 to $995,000, plus one at $1.87 million, the review shows. Buyers' average monthly principal and interest payment is about $3,400\. The homes are five condos, two townhomes and three single-family houses, and the buyers work for 12 local employers.

The city has paid $855,525 across the seven closings and committed $338,750 more, leaving $1,805,725 of this year's $3 million uncommitted, the review shows. That puts spending and commitments so far at $1,194,275, by the Independent's calculation.

By the Independent's calculation, the paid, committed and uncommitted figures add to exactly $3 million, the 2026 appropriation. The staff memo says that money included administrative costs, but the review doesn't break them out. Martin said the housing authority is paid "under a revenue-neutral approach, with a 'not to exceed,'" and that its pay is "included in the program's overall budget allocation." The Independent asked YVHA whether it is paid from program money, not how much; the city did not answer a question about administrative costs by the Independent's deadline.

## The resale question

The Local Residency restriction puts no cap on a home's resale price, but limits who can buy it to people who work locally. No Home Base home has resold yet, said Gates Gooding, who presented the deed restriction changes for city staff. People the city consulted in Vail and Eagle said residency-only restrictions there typically trade at a 15% to 20% discount to market, Gooding told council.

Barnes said almost all the research he could find shows the most successful programs have price appreciation caps. Speaking of restrictions without caps, he said "almost nowhere in mountain towns has it proved to be effective for the second owner." He also called the program for new buyers "great."

A council member said local loan officers report that some buyers who want the price-capped option back out once they run the numbers. Staff told council it planned to let the pilot play out, and that if only about 10% of buyers keep choosing the price cap, the payment amounts may need adjusting.

## What council discussed

Staff recommended adding $3 million for 2027 and carrying over about $1.8 million, for a 2027 budget of about $4.8 million. Asked whether they wanted to appropriate an additional $3 million, council members signaled support, and one asked to check the program again at six months.

In an informal vote, council members also backed raising the maximum payments to $195,000 for Local Residency and $325,000 for Price-Capped. Those maximums would extend the full 15% or 25% payment to homes priced up to $1.3 million, by the Independent's calculation. One council member backing a higher threshold said the hardest hurdle for many buyers is the down payment, not the monthly mortgage, and that it could help people "making really good money" who can't save one.

In an informal 6-1 vote, council members backed opening the program beyond city limits to the larger urban growth boundary. The vote against wasn't identified. At least two members called expanding premature; one noted that unincorporated Routt County already bars short-term rentals, so the move doesn't serve one of the program's goals. Council members also agreed not to pursue a third option that would have let employers buy homes for workers.

These were directions to staff, not final votes. Staff has said updates to the city's Affordable Housing Guidelines for Home Base will come to council in December or January.

The $3 million still needs a formal budget appropriation, and the records reviewed don't say when that vote will come.

## The city's case

Staff's memo describes Home Base as "opening up a pathway for new homeowners" in Steamboat Springs, and cites a city objective to increase housing options "to meet the diverse needs of residents across income levels." The review called the new-buyer pathway "Successful," with 10 transactions in four months, and the memo lists "no apparent legal issues." McCarthy told council the program is serving households from low to upper incomes.

Speakers at the meeting also defended the program. One said "I love this program" and called 10 sales in four months "actually pretty good," and another said it helps locals "stay in town."

## Open questions

- Why doesn't Home Base have an income limit or a maximum purchase price, and was that a deliberate choice?
- How does the city define "attainable" housing when it spends short-term rental tax money?
- Which restriction did the $1.87 million purchase use, and how much did the city pay toward it?
- How will the city tell whether Local Residency homes stay within reach of local buyers when they resell?
- When will council formally act on the higher maximums, the wider area and the 2027 money?
- How much did the program spend on administration in 2026, including the housing authority's fee?
- Is the ordinance's fiscal impact "None" because cure advances would come from the existing appropriation, and is there a cap on total advances?

The Yampa Valley Housing Authority answered the Independent's questions Friday; its answers appear above. The city did not respond by noon Friday, Nov. 20, the Independent's deadline, to questions sent Thursday.

*Disclosure: Emily McLarney, the wife of Independent editor and publisher Michael McLarney, serves on the city's Ad Hoc Housing Advisory Committee, which reviews requests for short-term rental tax money.*

*Correction: An earlier version of this story, published briefly Nov. 20, said at least one council member objected to adding $3 million for 2027\. A check of the meeting recording found the remark was a joke in favor of the money.*

## By the numbers

![Bar chart of Routt County households by income bracket, as a share of area median income: extremely low (under 30%) 12%, very low (31% to 50%) 14%, low (51% to 80%) 17%, moderate (81% to 120%) 14%, middle (121% to 140%) 6% and upper (over 140%) 37%. A marker shows the 10 Home Base buyers' incomes ranged from 64% to 231% of area median income and averaged 152%, in the upper bracket.](https://storage.ghost.io/c/aa/3a/aa3a9637-6f90-40b7-a01c-13f8ce5c1e50/content/images/2026/11/homebase_01_buyer_incomes_dark-2.png)

The buyers' average falls in the city's top income bracket, which holds 37% of all county households; the lowest-income buyer fell in the Low bracket.

![Chart showing that 114 households asked about Home Base Steamboat, 30 received approval letters and 10 have bought or are under contract, seven closed and three under contract, from the June 16, 2026 launch through Nov. 17.](https://storage.ghost.io/c/aa/3a/aa3a9637-6f90-40b7-a01c-13f8ce5c1e50/content/images/2026/11/homebase_02_inquiries_to_closings_dark-2.png)

An approval letter doesn't guarantee a payment, which depends on money being available, staff told council.

![Ten squares, one per household. Nine chose the Local Residency deed restriction, in which the city pays 15% of the price, up to $150,000, with no cap on resale price. One chose Price-Capped, in which the city pays 25%, up to $250,000, and appreciation is capped at 3% a year or less.](https://storage.ghost.io/c/aa/3a/aa3a9637-6f90-40b7-a01c-13f8ce5c1e50/content/images/2026/11/homebase_03_restriction_choice_dark-2.png)

Both restrictions limit who can buy the home later; only the Price-Capped one limits what it can sell for.

![Bar of the $3 million set aside for Home Base in 2026, as of Nov. 17: $855,525 paid at seven closings, $338,750 committed to three more and $1,805,725 not yet committed.](https://storage.ghost.io/c/aa/3a/aa3a9637-6f90-40b7-a01c-13f8ce5c1e50/content/images/2026/11/homebase_04_money_2026_dark-2.png)

Staff recommended carrying the uncommitted money into 2027 and adding $3 million more.

![Line chart of the city's payment by purchase price. Under current rules, Local Residency pays 15% of the price up to $150,000 and Price-Capped pays 25% up to $250,000, both reaching their maximums at a $1 million price. Under maximums of $195,000 and $325,000 that council backed in an informal vote Nov. 17 but has not formally adopted, the full percentage would apply to homes up to $1.3 million. Shading marks purchase prices so far, $455,000 to $995,000, plus one at $1.87 million.](https://storage.ghost.io/c/aa/3a/aa3a9637-6f90-40b7-a01c-13f8ce5c1e50/content/images/2026/11/homebase_05_payment_rules_dark-2.png)

Under the current rules, the full percentage applies to homes up to $1 million, by the Independent's calculation. Council backed the higher maximums in an informal vote Nov. 17, but they have not been formally adopted.

![Bar chart of households that expressed interest in Home Base, by occupation: other 42%, hospitality 19%, health care 18%, government 12% and education 9%.](https://storage.ghost.io/c/aa/3a/aa3a9637-6f90-40b7-a01c-13f8ce5c1e50/content/images/2026/11/homebase_06_interest_by_job_dark-2.png)

These figures cover every household that expressed interest, not only the 10 buyers, McCarthy told council.

## What's next

- **Tue., Dec. 1, 5 p.m.:** second reading of the Home Base deed restriction amendments, on the city's tentative agenda. Citizens' Meeting Room, Centennial Hall, 124 10th St., and on Zoom (meeting ID 985 289 877).
- **Tue., Dec. 8:** council work session. The tentative agenda lists a Home Base pilot program review.
- **December or January:** Affordable Housing Guidelines updates for Home Base, according to staff.
- **Public comment:** at either meeting in person or on Zoom, or by email to citycouncil@steamboatsprings.net.