Steamboat could adopt its planned stormwater fee without a public vote

City staff estimate the fee would raise about $3.5 million in its first year, and say council can adopt it by ordinance. Some council members said in 2025 that a city property tax lacked the support to pass. First in a series on how Steamboat pays its bills.

Share
Chart: in the city's December 2025 stormwater estimate, 11,800 of 15,055 billing units (78.4%) are on multifamily, commercial and other parcels and 3,255 (21.6%) on single-family homes.
Multifamily, commercial and other non-single-family parcels hold most of the planned fee's billing units, according to a preliminary city estimate from December 2025.

Key points

  • Steamboat Springs is planning a stormwater utility that would bill developed properties by their roofed and paved area. A city status report on council goals, in the Nov. 17 council packet, lists it in "a strategic funding strategy." Staff memos say council may enact the fee by ordinance; they don't mention a public vote.
  • City finance staff estimate about $3.5 million in the first year. About $1.8 million would cover stormwater costs the city already pays, freeing that money for other priorities.
  • Single-family homes would pay by size tier. Multifamily, commercial and other non-single-family parcels would pay by measured hard surface and hold 78.4% of the billing units, by the Independent's calculation. An industrial shop owner says he asked the city what he would pay and, as of Nov. 16, hadn't heard back.
  • Council members have differed on a city property tax: in 2025, some said it lacked support, while others called it the better model. The city says the fee would be dedicated to stormwater and would lessen its reliance on sales tax.
  • Council voted in December 2025 to have staff prepare a management plan and draft ordinance, the meeting video shows, though the approved minutes don't record the vote. The fee is on no posted council agenda through Jan. 5, and staff's plan shows revenue starting in 2028.

Steamboat Springs is planning a new monthly charge on developed property across town, billed by how much of each lot is roofed or paved. City finance staff estimate it could raise about $3.5 million in its first year, according to a July 14 memo from Finance Director Kim Weber.

"Note that a stormwater 'user fee' is not defined as a 'tax' in Colorado," a November 2025 staff memo told council. Local governments can set such fees by ordinance "as long as the revenue is segregated and dedicated" to the utility's mission, the memo says; council "may enact a fee and stormwater utility by ordinance," and the utility "would qualify as an enterprise under TABOR," outside the state constitution's limits on revenue, spending and borrowing. The city's memos don't mention a public vote. The state constitution lets city voters petition to refer local legislation to the ballot, and lets cities set the procedure. The city's only property tax, a 2-mill levy for fire and emergency medical services, was approved by voters in 2019.

A city status report on council goals, in the packet for the Nov. 17 council meeting, listed the stormwater utility as part of "a strategic funding strategy" council has endorsed, alongside folding the city fire department into the area fire district, a step staff have paired with a "possible ballot measure."

City staff say the fee would put drainage work on steady footing. The money would go into "a stormwater fund dedicated solely to the city's drainage infrastructure system and stormwater quality program," and the utility would reduce the city's "reliance on variable sales tax revenues," a December 2025 staff memo says.

What council members have said about a property tax

Council members have differed on a city property tax. At a June 10, 2025, work session on a proposed tax on vacant homes, Council member Bryan Swintek "stated that the City needs to pursue a property tax, but there was not the political will to do that," the minutes say. Then-Council President Pro Tem Joella West "does not think a property tax is realistic and is not timely," and then-Council member Dakotah McGinlay said a property tax "would hurt locals and would not garner support," according to the minutes. Council member Steve Muntean called a property tax "the more equitable route," paired with reducing the sales tax, the minutes say.

On Aug. 12, 2025, then-Council President Gail Garey argued for a tax on vacant homes; the minutes record her saying, "Any additional property tax burden is untenable." Swintek "would like to see a property tax next year" and said that once service cuts were felt, "a property tax would get support," and Muntean "agreed that the best model is a property tax," according to the minutes. Council dropped the vacancy tax that night. Muntean is now council president and Garey is president pro tem.

On the stormwater fee, council has kept moving. In November 2025, a majority chose the middle of three service levels, which the consultants said would complete a $16 million stormwater capital plan in 15 years instead of 20. Council member Dave Barnes, who preferred the lowest level, said "it is a big jump, and it will look like a tax to the community," according to the minutes. At a Feb. 10, 2026, goal-setting session, a majority agreed to "Move forward with developing the stormwater utility management plan." Barnes "does not support exploring a stormwater utility feeling like it is a 'revenue grab,'" the minutes say.

Who would pay, and how much

Single-family homes would pay by size tier. At the preliminary 2027 rates staff presented in December 2025 for the middle service level, a house with 3,001 to 6,000 square feet of roof and pavement would pay $19.90 a month, a smaller one $9.95 and a larger one $39.80. Homes with more than 12,000 square feet, about 2% of single-family customers, would be measured like other properties. Multifamily, commercial and other non-single-family parcels would be billed one unit for every 3,900 square feet of hard surface.

Those parcels hold 11,800 of the city's 15,055 billing units, or 78.4% by the Independent's calculation. The records don't say how many of those units are businesses. The city's consultants gave a sample bill of $660 a month for a grocery store with 128,000 square feet of hard surface. The city's advisory committee advised against offering rate credits at first, citing "the complexity, administrative burden, and loss of revenue," a staff memo says.

An industrial shop on 13th Street

Kelly Phillips, owner of Precision Repair Service and Sales, raised the fee with the Independent. The four-person business has operated since 1996, and he bought its 13th Street property in 2023, he said. The 1.1-acre lot is classified as industrial by the Routt County Assessor. Phillips ran for City Council in 2025 and lost the District 1 race to Garey, according to unofficial election-night results.

By his own calculation, his building and parking lots cover more than 22,000 square feet of hard surface. He said he asked Water Resources Manager Julie Baxter what the fee would cost his business each month and hadn't heard back as of Monday, Nov. 16. He said he was told the consultants haven't come up with a figure yet.

"The city is short on funds and it seems to me they have chosen local businesses to foot the bill," Phillips wrote. He expects council to adopt the fee and inclusionary zoning rules and to send a fire consolidation measure to voters next year, all on top of the half-cent regional transit sales tax that voters approved this month, according to unofficial results. If all three pass, he said, he will have to rethink owning a business in Steamboat. He said last winter was devastating to his business. "If we have another winter like the last one we will not survive," he wrote.

Phillips, who filled out the city's survey on the fee, wrote, "I think the city has done a very poor job of transparency and outreach." The city invited residents, businesses and property owners to an open house and online survey in December 2025. That month, Public Works Director Jon Snyder told council the next phase would bring a year of outreach, including "targeted outreach to larger property owners," and Barnes said "it feels rushed and the community does not know about it," according to the minutes. Homes would pay the fee too, and the records don't say what share businesses would carry.

Where the money would go

Weber's July memo quotes the problem statement council developed this year: "our current level of services have outpaced our revenue." About $1.8 million of the first year's $3.5 million "would be for expenses that are existing in the budget and would now be covered with [sic] by a new revenue source," the memo says. "This allows City Council to redirect the $1.8M to other priority items." For 2028, staff proposed using $800,000 for operations and $1 million for capital "to address inflationary pressures to maintain services as well as continue prioritized capital projects."

A schedule that slipped, and minutes that leave out a vote

In December 2025, staff's timeline called for preparing a draft ordinance "for final public hearings" between October and December 2026, with possible implementation Jan. 1, 2027. The fee is on no posted council agenda through Jan. 5. The proposed 2027 budget sets aside $25,000 for consultant help "if Council adopts the stormwater utility ordinance in 2027," and staff's July plan shows the first revenue in 2028.

The budget book says "City Council passed a resolution to move forward" with the management plan and draft ordinance. The Dec. 16, 2025, agenda listed the item as a motion; two weeks earlier, Snyder had told council the motion "does not create the utility" and would authorize staff to start the next phase, the minutes say. The meeting video shows Council member Amy Dickson moving to approve it, Barnes seconding and council approving it by voice vote, with no opposition heard. Muntean and Buccino were absent. The minutes council approved Feb. 3 record the staff presentation but not the motion, second or vote, though they record votes on the night's other items.

The city's case

City staff say Steamboat faces "between $30-65 million of deferred maintenance and capital projects" in its drainage system and tighter state stormwater permit rules. "Municipal utilities do not earn profits," a staff memo says, and a city presentation told council the utility "Frees up resources for other priorities like roads, parks, and public safety." An advisory committee that included a Steamboat Sheraton representative recommended a fee-for-service utility and supported extending the city's low-income and senior water and sewer discounts to the fee.

Would YVHA pay?

The Yampa Valley Housing Authority's finance team listed the fee as a concern Oct. 20. "The city's proposed fee has no affordable housing exemption and could affect all properties, starting with the 2027 or 2028 budget," say the minutes, which YVHA says are prepared with AI. Asked about it, YVHA said the idea of seeking exemptions or waivers was raised by a board member at that meeting, and that it is following the discussion and learning what the fee could mean for its properties. "We currently don't have a comment or position on the proposed fee," Communications Manager Laraine Martin wrote Nov. 18.

Responses

The city had not answered the Independent's questions as of Thursday morning, Nov. 19. They were emailed Sunday and Monday, Nov. 15-16, with a noon Tuesday deadline, and asked, among other things, whether council voted on the Dec. 16, 2025, motion and how many billing units Phillips's lot would have. YVHA's reply is above.

What's next

  • Dec. 1 and Dec. 15: council's next regular meetings. Their tentative agendas don't list the stormwater fee.
  • 2027: the proposed 2027 budget funds final steps if council adopts a stormwater utility ordinance next year.

Disclosure: During public comment at the Nov. 10 council meeting, the Independent's reporter, Anna Parashina, asked Council member Bryan Swintek to correct an Oct. 24 email in which he wrote that her name is a pen name.

Disclosure: Emily McLarney, wife of Independent editor and publisher Michael McLarney, serves on the city's Ad Hoc Housing Advisory Committee.

Disclosure: Kelly Phillips, who raised this story with the Independent, is a friend of Independent editor and publisher Michael McLarney.